Structure Augmented Long-Short Term Memory Network (StructLSTM) for Music Composition
Questions
Responses
41
Section 1 of 12
Form title
Form description
Email address*
Valid email address
Consent Form
*
Title
*
Description (optional)
Loading...
Loading...
I
confirm that I have had the project explained to me, and I have read
the participant information sheet, which I may keep for my records. I
understand this will involve listening to given music samples and
answering questions them. I understand that any information I provide is
confidential, and that no information that could lead to the
identification of any individual will be disclosed in any reports on the
project, or to any other party. No identifiable personal data will be
published. The identifiable data will not be shared with any other
organisation. I understand that my participation is voluntary, that I
can choose not to participate in part or all of the project, and that I
can withdraw at any stage of the project without being penalized or
disadvantaged in any way. I agree to City, University of London
recording and processing this information about me. I understand that
this information will be used only for the purpose(s) set out in this
statement and my consent is conditional on City complying with its
duties and obligations under the Data Protection Act 1998. I agree to
City, University of London recording and processing this information
about me. I understand that this information will be used only for the
purpose(s) set out in this statement and my consent is conditional on
City complying with its duties and obligations under the Data Protection
Act 1998. I agree to take part in the above study.
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
I confirm that I have had the project explained to me, and I have read the participant information sheet, which I may keep for my records. I understand this will involve listening to given music samples and answering questions them. I understand that any information I provide is confidential, and that no information that could lead to the identification of any individual will be disclosed in any reports on the project, or to any other party. No identifiable personal data will be published. The identifiable data will not be shared with any other organisation. I understand that my participation is voluntary, that I can choose not to participate in part or all of the project, and that I can withdraw at any stage of the project without being penalized or disadvantaged in any way. I agree to City, University of London recording and processing this information about me. I understand that this information will be used only for the purpose(s) set out in this statement and my consent is conditional on City complying with its duties and obligations under the Data Protection Act 1998. I agree to City, University of London recording and processing this information about me. I understand that this information will be used only for the purpose(s) set out in this statement and my consent is conditional on City complying with its duties and obligations under the Data Protection Act 1998. I agree to take part in the above study.
Loading image...
Caption
Other…
Add option
or
Add "Other"
…
Select at least
Select at most
Select exactly
Number
Custom error text
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Previous familiarity with musical concepts
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
Previous familiarity with musical concepts
Loading image...
Caption
Other…
Add option
or
Add "Other"
…
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Kindly Provide your Name/initials
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
Kindly Provide your Name/initials
Loading image...
Caption
Short-answer text
Response validation has been added.
Remove
Number
Text
Length
Regular expression
Greater than
Greater than or equal to
Less than
Less than or equal to
Equal to
Not equal to
Between
Not between
Is number
Whole number
Number
and
Number
Custom error text
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 2 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
Section 3 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
Loading...
Loading...
1a. In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
1a. In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
1b. How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
1b. How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
1c. How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
1c. How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
1d. In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
1d. In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
1e. How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
1e. How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 4 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
2 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
2 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
Loading...
Loading...
2 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
2 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
2 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
2 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
2 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
2 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
2 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
2 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
2 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
2 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 5 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
3 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
3 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
Loading...
Loading...
3 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
3 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
3 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
3 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
3 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
3 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
3 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
3 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
3 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
3 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 6 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
4 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
4 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
Loading...
Loading...
4 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
4 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
4 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
4 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
4 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
4 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
4 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
4 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
4 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
4 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 7 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
Loading...
Loading...
5 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
5 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
5 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
5 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
5 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
5 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
5 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
5 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
5 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
5 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 8 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
6 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
6 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
Loading...
Loading...
6 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
6 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
6 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
6 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
6 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
6 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
6 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
6 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
6 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
6 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 9 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
Loading...
Loading...
7 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
7 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
7 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
7 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
7 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
7 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
7 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
7 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
7 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
7 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 10 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
Untitled video
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
Untitled video
Loading...
Loading...
8 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
8 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
8 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
8 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
8 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
8 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
8 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
8 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
8 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
8 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 11 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
Untitled video
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
Untitled video
Loading...
Loading...
9 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
9 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
9 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
9 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
9 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
9 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
9 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
9 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
9 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
9 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
Section 12 of 12
Section title (optional)
Description (optional)
Untitled video
*
Untitled video
*
Caption for the video
Untitled video
Loading...
Loading...
10 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
10 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine
Loading image...
Caption
Human
Machine
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
10 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
10 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
10 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
10 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
10 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
10 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
10 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
*
Question
*
Question type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Drop-down
File upload
Linear scale
Multiple-choice grid
Tick box grid
Date
Time
Description
10 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Loading image...
Caption
Excellent
Poor
0
1
to
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
Label (optional)
5
Label (optional)
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading...
41 responses
The
number of responses collected by this form may exceed the limit
supported by Sheets. If you're having trouble viewing your responses in
Sheets, try downloading a .CSV instead.
Message for respondents
This form is no longer accepting responses
Summary
Question
Individual
Insights
Average
0/0 points
Median
0/0 points
Range
0-0 points
Total points distribution
Score
Count
-1
0
0
41
...
Loading...
Loading responses...
Consent Form
I
confirm that I have had the project explained to me, and I have read
the participant information sheet, which I may keep for my records. I
understand this will involve listening to given music samples and
answering questions them. I understand that any information I provide is
confidential, and that no information that could lead to the
identification of any individual will be disclosed in any reports on the
project, or to any other party. No identifiable personal data will be
published. The identifiable data will not be shared with any other
organisation. I understand that my participation is voluntary, that I
can choose not to participate in part or all of the project, and that I
can withdraw at any stage of the project without being penalized or
disadvantaged in any way. I agree to City, University of London
recording and processing this information about me. I understand that
this information will be used only for the purpose(s) set out in this
statement and my consent is conditional on City complying with its
duties and obligations under the Data Protection Act 1998. I agree to
City, University of London recording and processing this information
about me. I understand that this information will be used only for the
purpose(s) set out in this statement and my consent is conditional on
City complying with its duties and obligations under the Data Protection
Act 1998. I agree to take part in the above study.41 responses
Value
Count
I agree
41
41 (100%)
No responses yet for this question.
Previous familiarity with musical concepts41 responses
Not interested in music
1
Casual listener , appreciate good music but not familiar with musical concepts
25
Understand music theory and/or sing/play a musical instrument
10
Music professional / enthusiast
5
Music professional / enthusiast
No responses yet for this question.
Kindly Provide your Name/initials41 responses
JJ
TSR
TRK
A R
Tooba
Muaaz Bin
AHM
JC
ZM
Muhammad Awais Khan
SR
WJ
Mehreen Khan
Wasif Mir
WB
Smith T.
M
H Shahkhan
Buland ali
Waseem Abbas
Erum
Summaiya Siddique
Tamoor
Syeda samana rizvi
RG
Mushtaq Ahmed
Rida
Ko
Aisha Karim
TZ
Matthew
Jerry T.
malcolm snow
MS
James Tyler
Chris R
M rai
Jacob Stevens
K Ruth.
Asim shah
Adeel
No responses yet for this question.
Introduction
Listening Test 1
1a. In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
5
3
4
4
18
5
12
12 (29.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
1b. How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
9
3
11
4
18
5
2
2 (4.9%)
No responses yet for this question.
1c. How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
9
3
20
4
10
5
1
10 (24.4%)
No responses yet for this question.
1d. In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
4
3
4
4
21
5
11
11 (26.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
1e. How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
7
3
13
4
18
5
2
2 (4.9%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 2
2 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
4
2
9
3
11
4
12
5
5
5 (12.2%)
No responses yet for this question.
2 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
13
3
8
4
14
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
2 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
14
3
18
4
4
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
2 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
14
3
9
4
9
5
8
8 (19.5%)
No responses yet for this question.
2 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
3
2
10
3
17
4
8
5
3
8 (19.5%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 3
3 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
6
2
12
3
11
4
8
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
3 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
6
2
9
3
14
4
8
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
3 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
16
3
17
4
4
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
3 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
4
2
17
3
12
4
4
5
4
12 (29.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
3 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
14
3
15
4
7
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 4
4 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
4
2
7
3
13
4
9
5
8
8 (19.5%)
No responses yet for this question.
4 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
9
3
14
4
13
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
4 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
7
3
20
4
8
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
4 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
14
3
14
4
8
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
4 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
12
3
14
4
10
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 5
5 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
17
2
12
3
8
4
1
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
5 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
15
2
18
3
4
4
2
5
2
2 (4.9%)
No responses yet for this question.
5 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
18
2
10
3
8
4
2
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
5 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
18
2
12
3
6
4
3
5
2
2 (4.9%)
No responses yet for this question.
5 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
12
2
16
3
7
4
3
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 6
6 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
5
2
16
3
9
4
5
5
6
6 (14.6%)
No responses yet for this question.
6 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
5
2
13
3
15
4
5
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
6 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
5
2
19
3
10
4
4
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
6 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
21
3
7
4
6
5
5
5 (12.2%)
No responses yet for this question.
6 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
7
2
16
3
9
4
6
5
3
3 (7.3%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 7
7 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
11
3
7
4
10
5
11
10 (24.4%)
No responses yet for this question.
7 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
0
2
10
3
8
4
18
5
5
5 (12.2%)
No responses yet for this question.
7 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
0
2
4
3
15
4
15
5
7
7 (17.1%)
No responses yet for this question.
7 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
8
3
12
4
13
5
6
6 (14.6%)
No responses yet for this question.
7 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
8
3
13
4
13
5
6
6 (14.6%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 8
8 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
7
2
8
3
10
4
12
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
8 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
1
2
15
3
10
4
11
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
8 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
2
2
16
3
16
4
5
5
2
5 (12.2%)
No responses yet for this question.
8 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
3
2
17
3
8
4
7
5
6
6 (14.6%)
No responses yet for this question.
8 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
3
2
12
3
16
4
6
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 9
9 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
9
2
18
3
9
4
5
5
0
0 (0%)
No responses yet for this question.
9 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
0
2
19
3
17
4
4
5
1
1 (2.4%)
No responses yet for this question.
9 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
8
2
16
3
13
4
3
5
1
1 (2.4%)
No responses yet for this question.
9 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
4
2
21
3
6
4
8
5
2
2 (4.9%)
No responses yet for this question.
9 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
4
2
22
3
9
4
4
5
2
2 (4.9%)
No responses yet for this question.
Listening Test 10
10 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine41 responses
Value
Count
1
23
2
11
3
3
4
4
5
0
0 (0%)
No responses yet for this question.
10 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
12
2
16
3
10
4
2
5
1
1 (2.4%)
No responses yet for this question.
10 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition?41 responses
Value
Count
1
17
2
16
3
6
4
1
5
1
1 (2.4%)
No responses yet for this question.
10 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? 41 responses
Value
Count
1
15
2
18
3
4
4
3
5
1
1 (2.4%)
No responses yet for this question.
10 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?41 responses
Value
Count
1
11
2
20
3
5
4
1
5
4
4 (9.8%)
No responses yet for this question.
Waiting for responses
of
41
Responses cannot be edited
Structure Augmented Long-Short Term Memory Network (StructLSTM) for Music Composition
PARTICIPANT INFORMATION:
We would like to invite you to take part in a research study. Before you decide whether you would like to take part it is important that you understand why the research is being done and what it would involve for you. Please take time to read the following information carefully and discuss it with others if you wish. Ask us if there is anything that is not clear or if you would like more information.
The primary research question, that this project attempts to answer is:
"Can we improve the performance of a Recurrent Deep Neural Network architecture by augmenting structural knowledge using a Language Modelling framework, in order to stochastically generate musical sequences while enforcing structural and metrical constraints on the generative process"
You have been invited to participate in this study in the capacity of listener/ musicians/ professionals or an enthusiast. This survey has been designed to get your feedback on the music generated by the model mentioned above. Your participation in this survey is is voluntary, and you can choose not to participate in part or all of the project. You can withdraw at any stage of the project without being penalised or disadvantaged in any way. It is up to you to decide whether or not to take part. If you do decide to take part you will be asked to sign a consent form. If you decide to take part you are still free to withdraw at any time and without giving a reason.
The survey will take about 10 - 15 minutes of your time where you will asked to listen to a few musical sequences (including human performances and computer generated melodies). You will then be asked to answer a few questions about each musical sequence you have listened. The information provided by you will primarily be used to evaluate the performance of the model in a Turing style evaluation. There are no potential disadvantages for you if you take part in this study. Your participation, however, will contribute towards the developments in the field of Artificial Intelligence, Neural computing and music informatics. We do not ask any personal information from you except your previous musical knowledge and your initials to satisfy the consent and ethics requirements. At the end of the study you will be notified with the results. Thank you for your time and effort.
Shakeel Raja
*Required
Consent Form
Kindly read following information and click on "I agree" to proceed.
I
confirm that I have had the project explained to me, and I have read
the participant information sheet, which I may keep for my records. I
understand this will involve listening to given music samples and
answering questions them. I understand that any information I provide is
confidential, and that no information that could lead to the
identification of any individual will be disclosed in any reports on the
project, or to any other party. No identifiable personal data will be
published. The identifiable data will not be shared with any other
organisation. I understand that my participation is voluntary, that I
can choose not to participate in part or all of the project, and that I
can withdraw at any stage of the project without being penalized or
disadvantaged in any way. I agree to City, University of London
recording and processing this information about me. I understand that
this information will be used only for the purpose(s) set out in this
statement and my consent is conditional on City complying with its
duties and obligations under the Data Protection Act 1998. I agree to
City, University of London recording and processing this information
about me. I understand that this information will be used only for the
purpose(s) set out in this statement and my consent is conditional on
City complying with its duties and obligations under the Data Protection
Act 1998. I agree to take part in the above study. *
Required
Previous familiarity with musical concepts *
Kindly Provide your Name/initials *
JJ
Introduction
These tests will require you to listen to a mix of different human and machine composed musical sequences . You are requested to listen to these samples with following considerations and give a score for each question, for all sequences. Kindly answer all questions and give a mean score of 3 if you remain indecisive.
1. Likelihood of the sequence generated by a human vs. an intelligent computational algorithm. You are required to give a score based on your previous experience of listening to different kinds of music. Human compositions are normally identified as having a "soul" or a deeper emotional impact on the listener while computer generated music, although can sound musically correct, they might lack in the emotional dimension.
2. Long term musical structure: The long term structure (or global structure) of a musical composition is identified by the similarity between different parts of the song and how these parts are repeated within the composition. The long term structure is usually understood in terms of intro, chorus, verse, bridge and outro. While giving a score for long term structure, you are required to listen for similar grouping of bars, repeating within the music. If a part gets repeated, it may be a sign that the composition is bound by a global or a long term structure.
3. Short term musical structure: The short term structure of a musical composition is defined by the combinations and repetition of notes within adjacent beats and bars. The rhythm, metre (time signature) and key of the composition usually define the short term structure of musical patterns within a compositions. You are required to look for combinations of notes (phrases), their short term repetitions holding the rhythm of the music and how well this rhythm is maintained.
4. How well does the song conclude? You are required to focus on the conclusion (ending) of the composition and give your opinion, based on your past listening experience if the song has concluded in a good manner, or did it end abruptly.
5. How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence? You are required to give each sequence a score based on how pleasent the sequence sounded to you.
** you can hit BACK at any stage to come back to this information **
Listening Test 1
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
1a. In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
1b. How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
1c. How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
1d. In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
1e. How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 2
2 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
2 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
2 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
2 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
2 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
2 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 3
3 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
3 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
3 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
3 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
3 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
3 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 4
4 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
4 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
4 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
4 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
4 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
4 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 5
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
5 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
5 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
5 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
5 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
5 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 6
6 Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
6 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
6 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
6 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
6 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
6 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 7
Listen to the music based on the criteria described above.
7 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
7 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
7 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
7 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
7 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 8
8 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
8 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
8 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
8 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
8 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 9
9 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
9 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
9 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
9 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
9 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?
Excellent
Poor
Listening Test 10
10 In your opinion, what is the likelihood of the music composed by human vs. machine *
Human
Machine
10 How do you rate the long term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
10 How do you rate the short term structure of this composition? *
Excellent
Poor
10 In your opinion, how well does the composition come to a conclusion (ending) ? *
Excellent
Poor
10 How would you score overall quality of this musical sequence?